Haley Reed and her stepbrother Logan Long have both been ordered by the choir director to practice their singing even though Logan is more interested in playing football. Deciding to cause trouble, Logan gets on his knees behind Haley and lifts her gown so he can finger bang her landing strip fuck hole. When the choir dad catches Logan in the act, he tells him to sit in the corner and wear the sinner dunce hat.

Not to be dissuaded, Logan gets up and goes right back to Haley as soon as the choir dad's back is turned. Soon Haley is on her knees while Logan pounds her creamy fuck hole from behind. When Logan takes a seat on the chair, Haley is happy to slide down on his fuck stick until she's fully impaled. Her hips bump and grind while the choir dad remains oblivious. As she reaches down to rub her clit and make herself cum, it becomes a challenge to keep up with the song that she's supposed to be singing without letting on that she's about to climax.

Sitting down on the chair, Haley spreads her thighs and invites Logan back into her tight fuck hole. This time he doesn't let up after getting his lover off. As he's in the process of filling Haley with a creampie of jizz, they once are caught once again by the choir dad, who orders them both to cleanse themselves and meet him in the confessional.